Attribute | # of studies | % of studies (%) | Study citations |
---|---|---|---|
Setting | |||
 US setting | 5 | 33 | Moschetti et al. [24], Stojanovic et al. [29], Sharples et al. [28], Genders et al. [20], Ge et al. [13, 31] |
 European setting (including the UK) | 11 | 73 | Walker et al. [14], Boldt et al. [22], Thom et al. [30], Petrov et al. [25], Pontone et al. [27], Pletscher et al. [26], Moschetti et al. [24], Sharples et al. [28], Genders et al. [20], Campbell et al. [23], Walker et al. [31] |
 Other setting | 2 | 13 | |
Comparators included | |||
 No imaging | 2 | 13 | |
 Stress echocardiography | 4 | 27 | Thom et al. [30], Sharples et al. [28], Genders et al. [20], Bertoldi et al. [21] |
 Stress electrocardiography | 4 | 27 | Walker et al. [14], Pletscher et al. [26], Bertoldi et al. [21], Walker et al. [31] |
 SPECT | 11 | 73 | Walker et al. [14], Boldt et al. [22], Thom et al. [30], Pletscher et al. [26], Sharples et al. [28], Genders et al. [20], Stojanovic et al. [29], Sharples et al. [28], Ge et al. [13], Walker et al. [31], Kozor et al. [32], Walker et al. [31] |
 CCTA | 5 | 33 | Pontone et al. [27], Genders et al. [20], Bertoldi et al. [21], Ge et al. [13] |
 Immediate coronary angiography | 10 | 67 | Walker et al. [14], Boldt et al. [22], Thom et al. [30], Petrov et al. [25], Pletscher et al. [26], Moschetti et al. [24], Sharples et al. [28], Ge et al. [13], Walker et al. [31], Kozor et al. [32] |
Main conclusion on CMR value | |||
 CMR cost-effective | 10 | 67 | Walker et al. [14], Boldt et al. [22], Petrov et al. [25], Pontone et al. [27], Pletscher et al. [26], Moschetti et al. [24], Stojanovic et al. [29], Ge et al. [13], Walker et al. [31], Kozor et al. [32] |
 CMR not cost-effective | 2 | 13 | |
 Unclear cost-effectiveness | 3 | 20 | Thom et al. [30], Sharples et al. [28], Campbell et al. [23] |
Key drivers of cost-effectiveness results | |||
 Underlying CAD prevalence | 9 | 60 | Walker et al. [14], Boldt et al. [22], Thom et al. [30], Pletscher et al. [26], Moschetti et al. [24], Stojanovic et al. [29], Genders et al. [20], Ge et al. [13], Kozor et al. [32] |
 Test costs | 4 | 27 | Pletscher et al. [26], Moschetti et al. [24], Sharples et al. [28], Bertoldi et al. [21] |
Perspective taken | |||
 Societal | 1 | 8 | Genders et al. [20] |
 Healthcare system or payer | 10 | 67 | Walker et al. [14], Boldt et al. [22], Pletscher et al. [26], Moschetti et al. [24], Stojanovic et al. [29], Bertoldi et al. [21], Campbell et al. [23], Ge et al. [13], Walker et al. [31], Kozor et al. [32] |
 Hospital | 1 | 7 | Stojanovic et al. [29] |
 Not clearly stated | 4 | 27 | Thom et al. [30], Petrov et al. [25], Pontone et al. [27], Sharples et al. [28] |
Model time horizon | |||
 Lifetime | 7 | 47 | Walker et al. [14], Pletscher et al. [26], Genders et al. [20], Bertoldi et al. [21], Campbell et al. [23], Ge et al. [13], Kozor et al. [32] |
 10–30 years | 2 | 13 | |
 3–10 years | 1 | 7 | Thom et al. [30] |
 < 3 years | 4 | 27 | Pontone et al. [27], Stojanovic et al. [29], Sharples et al. [28], Walker et al. [31] |
 Not stated | 1 | 7 | Moschetti et al. [24] |